Posted by Bob Greenberger on November 19, 2012
Marvel’s corporate history is at least as compelling as the Earth-616 universe it has published since 1961. We’ve had some glimpses via the Les Daniels’ Marvel: Five Fabulous Decades of the World’s Greatest Comics and bits scattered in other works, notably Gerry Jones’ wonderful Men of Tomorrow. For the mass consumer, Sean Howe has offered up Marvel Comics The Untold Story but for those who grew up reading the comics, it is woefully short on analysis and perspective.
Martin Goodman built a publishing empire based on having a good gut, sensing when something was hot and flooding the market with titles that fed that interest. Once tastes changed, so did the magazines, building a successful company based entirely on short-term goals. That philosophy long outlasted Goodman, who cashed out in 1971 and the company really didn’t begin looking at a long-term game plan until it emerged from bankruptcy in 1997, firmly in the grip of miserly Ike Perlmutter.
Howe’s book breezily takes us from inception through the last year or so, but unevenly weights his sections so seems fascinated by the 1970s second generation of Marvel creators, which matches the first decade of his life. The first two decades is quickly dispatched in under 50 pages which means we learn little of how the company really worked and the personalities surrounding young Stan Lee. As a result, the great Al Jaffe’s tenure as an editor in the 1950s is missing and Vince Fago, who ran the shop while Lee served in World War II, is given barely more than a line. The brief superhero revival in the early 1950s barely gets a notice including that Sub-Mariner outlasted the others while Goodman held out to see if a television option would get picked up.
Goodman and Lee made an effective combination because Lee was versatile and could change direction at his relative’s whim. If Goodman wanted ten new funny animal books, then Lee was happily writing Ziggy Pig followed by a decade of Millie the Model. It was through Lee’s determination that the company held on when first the Senate Hearings crushed other, weaker publishers and then in 1957 when Goodman’s change in distribution left him with in a tenuous situation. Little is really made of what it must have been like to be limited to eight titles a month by Independent News, owned by rival DC Comics. And very little time is spent on showing how the shifting tastes of the 1950s meant a carefully readjusting of the line until Goodman one day ordered a superhero series to compete with DC’s revived heroes.
Howe’s work skips along and misses a chance to explore interesting areas of growth such as 1966 when the company really exploded into licensing from Aurora model kits to toys and Halloween costumes. The first of a long string of disastrous media deals, the stiffly animated Marvel Super Hero cartoons, but he never connects the dots to point out Goodman never before had a chance to exploit his properties and not once brought on a qualified licensing agent.
In fact, Marvel’s publishing and licensing suffered for something close to thirty years from unqualified or disinterested people treating the company like a widget producer rather than an intellectual property company. New World’s Bob Rehme is shown to have ignored due diligence, thinking he bought Superman when he actually bought Spider-Man. Goodman sold it to a company that aspired to be Warner Communications but had no feel for its acquisitions, a situation repeated all the way up to Perlmutter, who finally recognized how valuable Spider-Man and his friends were. As a result, when Lee and then Roy Thomas left the editor-in-chief’s spot, there was no senior management to groom and train replacements so there was a revolving door until Jim Shooter wound up winning the job almost by default.
The book does a good job pointing out that it had a hit on its hands with Steve Gerber’s Howard the Duck but had no one in a position to exploit him in a careful manner leading to a poor comic strip and terrible feature film, squandering the property. It’s also interesting to note that the first feature films were by characters not from the fabled days of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby but Gerber’s Duck and Marv Wolfman’s Blade (culled from the overlooked Tomb of Dracula). Lee’s marginalization after becoming publisher and then figurehead is nicely detailed and again, a wasted opportunity although he was always quick to curry favor with whoever had the properties rather than fight for their integrity (see CBS’ Spider-Man).
Howe carefully chronicles the rise and fall of Shooter, thanks to the growth of comics journalism, led by The Comics Journal. To his credit, Shooter stabilized the line and actually had an editorial direction in mind until he focused entirely on picayune matters, losing the respect of the editors and freelancers. The author misses out demonstrating that as Shooter shouted about clarity, his rival, Jenette Kahn spent a decade turning DC into a strong competitor, introducing royalties and new formats taking advantage of improved printing technologies, leveraging the growth of the comics shops and their dedicated customers. Nor does Howe mention how the Marvel Handbook and Secret Wars were also designed as ways to blunt their rivals’ 50th anniversary projects Who’s Who and Crisis on Infinite Earths.
As he carefully chronicles the rise of the generation that formed Image, his research fails him time and again. For example, Rob Liefeld was drawing the Hawk & Dove miniseries for DC, as editor Mike Carlin tried to carefully art direct the enthusiastic and artistically limited young man. During this time, Bob Harras blew enough smoke up Rob’s ass to lure him to Marvel where any attempt at training and improving him was abandoned. DC even offered at least one project to Todd McFarlane (who got his start there with Infinity Inc., where he cleverly decorated his pages to hide his drawing flaws) to write when it was clear he wanted to stretch as a creator. It was a movie adaptation, a chance to train him how to write before moving on to big projects but Marvel just gave him the keys to the Webslinger and lived to regret it.
While Howe credits Marvel with innovating the cover gimmicks that were a hallmark of the 1990s, he avoids statistical analysis to demonstrate how the company was also working to strangle the smaller independent publishers. On the other hand, he appropriately lionizes Carol Kalish, who was the one person working with retailers to grow the field and was taking a long view.
However, poor editing means people drop in and out of the narrative without introduction or context. After writing in the early 1970s, Mike Friedich vanished and his return as the company’s first Direct Sales manager is glossed over. Similarly, Kurt Busiek’s first appearance in the book is by surname only and without context. Other key players drop in and out so we lose track of Ed Shukin (left for DC), editorial coordinator Jim Sokolowski (fired before turning up at High Times, DC, Marvel, and now Archie), and Virginia Romita who effectively replaced John Verpoorten as the tight-fisted production manager (if there’s anything Howe does right, it’s emphasizing Big John’s importance to the Marvel). Considering he spoke with 150 or so people himself, and had the riches of fan media at his disposal, I expected fresher perspectives and information.
Marvel’s relationships with its talent has always been iffy, starting with stiffing Jack Kirby and Joe Simon on promised royalties on Captain America in the 1940s through today. They were rarely interested in treating them with dignity or respect, counting on Stan’s rah-rah relationships to keep things cordial. Jack’s increasingly sour attitudes towards Marvel and his collaborator shows the limitations of backslaps and nicknames. They were slow to return art, pay reprint fees, initiate incentives (aka royalties) and cut the talent in for credit. DC bent over backwards to compensate talent whenever characters from the comics were used in other media. Len Wein has lived off bonuses for Lucius Fox in Batman animated fare and feature films while he’s never gotten so much as a free movie ticket for creating Wolverine. The company has remained notoriously stingy over comp copies of comics produced by writers and artists, let alone sent samples of merchandise where their words and pictures have been repurposed for Marvel’s profit.
Under Perlmutter, Marvel and Toy Biz combined operations and brought Bill Jemas in as president and in turn, he elevated Joe Quesada to editor in chief. As Perlmutter and Avi Arad finally got Marvel on the right track in media, Jemas and Quesada fixed the House that Stan, Jack, and Steve built. Systematically, they tackled one franchise, starting with Spidey, then another, X-Men. He didn’t understand or like Tom Brevoort’s mainstream superhero titles but respected their sales and largely left him alone, making Brevoort nearly bulletproof. More should have been said about Tom’s growth into the keeper of the Flame, inherited in the wake of Mark Gruenwald’s tragic heart attack. Editors rose and fell in favor with Jemas and once they lost his interest, they were quickly gone with a new target in his sight. Jemas was brash and cut through the malaise that a decade of uncertainty allowed to become the status quo. He was right that the continuity was cumbersome and the Ultimate line was a commercial stroke of genius. His successes let him have fun and he never tired of poking DC’s Paul Levtiz, Bob Wayne, and others. When he decided Marvel was withdrawing from the Comics Magazine Association of America in favor of an in-house ratings system, he packed the conference room with every former DC employee even though none had any business being in the room. It had to have been the most uncomfortable meeting Axel Alonso, Stuart Moore, Jenny Lee, or I ever attended.
Like Shooter before him, success led to a period of bizarre behavior that ultimately cost them their jobs. But under new President Dan Buckley, Quesada and Alonso, the company has set its sights on a future, organically working to achieve that goal. Howe once again misses a chance to analyze what this has meant across the board, skipping the rise of the Marvel Studios films, beginning with Iron Man and the cadre of Marvel talent consulting on them to keep them as close to the comics as is practical.
The entire final five years or so reads like a rough draft and merited far more attention, explaining how the company’s stability and growth potential was catnip to Disney, desperate for that very demographic it lacked.
The Untold Story goes down easy for the mass market, its audience, but it falls far short from what the regular readers, those of us who toiled for the firm or have supported their titles for decades, would have preferred to read. Once more, the core is taken for granted as Howe attempts to convince an unsuspecting public he’s found all the dirt and stories worth telling. Of course, there’s far, far more worth exploring.
Comments15 Responses to “So, I read Marvel Comics The Untold Story”
Leave a comment, and if you'd like your own picture to show up next to your comments, go get a gravatar!